Best Plush Toy Shops In New York Near You

Who has selected these businesses:
Ali Lemer
@alilemer
Author and references

Sort by:
Relevance
Add my business

1. FAO Schwarz

3091 reviews
FAO Schwarz
Location
5
Prices
5
Product Quality
5
Establishment
5
Customer service
5

Address: 30 Rockefeller Plaza, New York, NY 10111

Schedule: Opens at 11:00 AM

Telephone: (800) 326-8638

Guy: Toy store


Review: "There's all sorts of stuffed animals to creative/drawing toys, discovery ..."

There are no offers available.


Near FAO Schwarz:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

2. Mary Arnold Toys

140 reviews
Mary Arnold Toys
Location
5
Prices
5
Product Quality
5
Establishment
5
Customer service
5

Address: 1178 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10028

Schedule: Opens at 9:30 AM

Telephone: (212) 744-8510

Guy: Toy store


Review: "NYC oldest and best Toy Store in Manhattan."

There are no offers available.


Near Mary Arnold Toys:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

3. Kidding Around

232 reviews
Kidding Around
Location
5
Prices
5
Product Quality
5
Establishment
5
Customer service
5

Address: 60 West 15th Street #, 1 # 1, New York, NY 10011

Schedule: Opens at 10:00 AM

Telephone: (212) 645-6337

Guy: Toy store


Review: "This is the best toy store, hands down!"

There are no offers available.


Near Kidding Around:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

4. Disney Store

8215 reviews
Disney Store
Location
5
Prices
5
Product Quality
5
Establishment
5
Customer service
5

Address: 1540 Broadway, New York, NY 10036

Schedule: Opens at 11:00 AM

Telephone: (212) 626-2910

Guy: Toy store


Review: "But defently one of the best toys store in NY city if you like Disney"

There are no offers available.


Near Disney Store:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

5. Norman & Jules

54 reviews
Norman & Jules
Location
4.7
Prices
4.1
Product Quality
5
Establishment
4.3
Customer service
4

Address: 68 3rd St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Schedule: Opens at 11:00 AM

Telephone: (347) 987-3323

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near Norman & Jules:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

6. Build-A-Bear Workshop

628 reviews
Build-A-Bear Workshop
Location
4.2
Prices
4.9
Product Quality
4.8
Establishment
5
Customer service
4.6

Address: 22 W 34th St, New York, NY 10001

Schedule: Opens at 10:00 AM

Telephone: (212) 863-4070

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near Build-A-Bear Workshop:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

7. Toy Tokyo

1057 reviews
Toy Tokyo
Location
4
Prices
4.7
Product Quality
4.8
Establishment
4.7
Customer service
4

Address: 91 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003

Schedule: Opens at 1:00 PM

Telephone: (212) 673-5424

Guy: Toy store


Review: "The best toy store in Manhattan!"

There are no offers available.


Near Toy Tokyo:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

8. Greenpoint Toys

80 reviews
Greenpoint Toys
Location
4.3
Prices
4.1
Product Quality
5
Establishment
4.9
Customer service
4.7

Address: 738 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222

Schedule: Opens at 10:00 AM

Telephone: (718) 383-3437

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near Greenpoint Toys:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

9. Boomerang Toys

84 reviews
Boomerang Toys
Location
4.8
Prices
4.6
Product Quality
4
Establishment
4.9
Customer service
4.4

Address: 119 W Broadway, New York, NY 10013

Schedule: Opens at 10:30 AM

Telephone: (212) 226-7650

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near Boomerang Toys:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

10. Mini Jake

47 reviews
Mini Jake
Location
4.5
Prices
4.4
Product Quality
5
Establishment
4.1
Customer service
4.6

Address: 178 N 9th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

Schedule: Opens at 11:30 AM

Telephone: (718) 782-2005

Guy: Baby store


Review: "Honestly, this is the best independent toy story I've ever seen."

There are no offers available.


Near Mini Jake:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

11. West Side Kids

133 reviews
West Side Kids
Location
4.3
Prices
4
Product Quality
4.2
Establishment
4.5
Customer service
4.7

Address: 498 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024

Schedule: Opens at 11:00 AM

Telephone: (212) 496-7282

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near West Side Kids:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

12. myplasticheart

148 reviews
myplasticheart
Location
4.7
Prices
4.9
Product Quality
4.2
Establishment
4.7
Customer service
4.5

Address: 40 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222

Telephone: (646) 290-6866

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near myplasticheart:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

13. Steven Smith Stuffed Animals

8 reviews
Steven Smith Stuffed Animals
Location
4.2
Prices
4.3
Product Quality
4.9
Establishment
4
Customer service
4.2

Address: 330 E 89th St, Brooklyn, NY 11236

Telephone: (718) 272-2500

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near Steven Smith Stuffed Animals:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

14. Little Things Toy Store

40 reviews
Little Things Toy Store
Location
4.5
Prices
4.5
Product Quality
4.2
Establishment
4.4
Customer service
4.3

Address: 159 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Schedule: Opens at 10:30 AM

Telephone: (917) 909-0987

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near Little Things Toy Store:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

15. Grandma's Place

107 reviews
Grandma's Place
Location
4.6
Prices
4.6
Product Quality
4.8
Establishment
4.3
Customer service
4.6

Address: 84 W 120th St, New York, NY 10027

Schedule: Opens at 10:00 AM

Telephone: (212) 360-6776

Guy: Toy store


Review: "The little ones could choose a kite, puppet, stuffed animal or book to ..."

There are no offers available.


Near Grandma's Place:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

16. Build-A-Bear Workshop - FAO Schwarz

30 reviews
Build-A-Bear Workshop - FAO Schwarz
Location
4.1
Prices
4.9
Product Quality
4.2
Establishment
4
Customer service
4.1

Address: FAO Store Room, 45 Rockefeller Plaza, c/o, New York, NY 10112

Schedule: Opens at 11:00 AM

Telephone: (212) 863-2384

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near Build-A-Bear Workshop - FAO Schwarz:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

17. PIQ SoHo

22 reviews
PIQ SoHo
Location
4.4
Prices
4.1
Product Quality
4.1
Establishment
4.7
Customer service
4.8

Address: 420 Broadway, New York, NY 10013

Schedule: Opens at 11:00 AM

Telephone: (646) 559-4431

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near PIQ SoHo:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

18. Playing Mantis

54 reviews
Playing Mantis
Location
5
Prices
4.8
Product Quality
4.5
Establishment
5
Customer service
4.8

Address: 32 N Moore St, New York, NY 10013

Schedule: Opens at 11:00 AM

Telephone: (646) 484-6845

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near Playing Mantis:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

19. HomBom Toys

45 reviews
HomBom Toys
Location
4.6
Prices
4.2
Product Quality
4.2
Establishment
4.5
Customer service
4.2

Address: 1500 1st Ave, New York, NY 10075

Schedule: Opens at 12:00 PM

Telephone: (212) 717-5300

Guy: Toy store


There are no offers available.


Near HomBom Toys:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

Every week our algorithms find new sites and we only recommend the top 20 . next update in 209 minutes.


⭐️ If you promote or add your business, your listing will be permanent on this list.

We help you choose plush toy shops in New York

Looking for plush toy shops in New York? Then you've come to the right place, because we're all experts in it and all things New York!
We've got our finger on the pulse of the city, and we'll keep you up to date on the best places to eat, sleep and have a great time New York. Don't hesitate any longer, join us and use us in the palm of your hand to make sure you don't miss a single corner of one of the world's top cities - you're looking for plush toy shops in New York and here we are!
Don't just stop at the Empire State Building, MoMA or Central Park. Here you have everything and more available and updated for you to make the most of this city. Plans, hidden corners, and the most curious facts that can help you whether it's a trip for a couple of days or setting up a move New York.
Use us in your own way and find hundreds of useful posts about New York!