Best Olive Oil Shops In New York Near You

Who has selected these businesses:
Ali Lemer
@alilemer
Author and references

Sort by:
Relevance
Add my business

1. O Live Brooklyn

36 reviews
O Live Brooklyn
Location
5
Prices
5
Product Quality
5
Establishment
5
Customer service
5

Address: 140 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, United States

Schedule: Opens at 10:00

Telephone: +1 718-783-1680

Guy: Gourmet grocery store


Review: "I love my Brooklyn Olive oil, best olive oil in town."

There are no offers available.


Near O Live Brooklyn:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

2. Little Gypsy Farms 🧿 Estate Grown Extra Virgin Olive Oil

4 reviews
Little Gypsy Farms 🧿 Estate Grown Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Location
5
Prices
5
Product Quality
5
Establishment
5
Customer service
5

Address: 527 Hudson St #20054, New York, NY 10014, United States

Guy: Olive oil manufacturer


There are no offers available.


Near Little Gypsy Farms 🧿 Estate Grown Extra Virgin Olive Oil:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

3. Murray's Cheese


911 reviews
Murray's Cheese
Location
4.3
Prices
4.3
Product Quality
4.7
Establishment
4.6
Customer service
4.2

Address: 254 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, United States

Schedule: Opens at 10:00

Guy: Cheese shop


Review: "Take home jams or honeycomb, or pick up an olive oil..."

There are no offers available.


Near Murray's Cheese:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

4. Duals Natural

96 reviews
Duals Natural
Location
4.5
Prices
4.9
Product Quality
4.4
Establishment
4
Customer service
5

Address: 91 1st Ave 91 1st Ave Store Below, New York, NY 10003, United States

Schedule: Open until 23:00

Telephone: +1 212-979-6045

Guy: Health food store


There are no offers available.


Near Duals Natural:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

5. Olive That & More


17 reviews
Olive That & More
Location
4.9
Prices
4.3
Product Quality
4.3
Establishment
4.5
Customer service
5

Address: 298 Bloomfield Ave, Verona, NJ 07044, United States

Schedule: Opens at 10:00

Telephone: +1 973-744-7175

Guy: Gourmet grocery store


Review: "Steve is amazing and if course the oil is great"

There are no offers available.


Near Olive That & More:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

6. Murray's Cheese

197 reviews
Murray's Cheese
Location
5
Prices
4
Product Quality
5
Establishment
4.7
Customer service
4.4

Address: 89 E 42nd St, New York, NY 10017, United States

Schedule: Opens at 8:00

Telephone: +1 212-922-1540

Guy: Cheese shop


Review: "Prices are high, especially on items like olives & other accompaniments"

There are no offers available.


Near Murray's Cheese:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

7. Zabar's


3927 reviews
Zabar's
Location
4.7
Prices
4.1
Product Quality
4.1
Establishment
4.6
Customer service
4.1

Address: 2245 Broadway, New York, NY 10024, United States

Schedule: Opens at 8:00

Telephone: +1 212-787-2000

Guy: Gourmet grocery store


Review: "Check out their olive best and ground-to- order coffee."

There are no offers available.


Near Zabar's:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

8. Agata & Valentina

571 reviews
Agata & Valentina
Location
4.2
Prices
4.5
Product Quality
4.7
Establishment
4.6
Customer service
4.9

Address: 1505 1st Ave, New York, NY 10021, United States

Schedule: Opens at 8:00

Telephone: +1 212-452-0690

Guy: Gourmet grocery store


Review: "Very nice selection of olive oils."

There are no offers available.


Near Agata & Valentina:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

9. Di Palo's Fine Foods


470 reviews
Di Palo's Fine Foods
Location
4.2
Prices
4.2
Product Quality
4.5
Establishment
4.7
Customer service
4.6

Address: 200 Grand St, New York, NY 10013, United States

Schedule: Opens at 9:30

Telephone: +1 212-226-1033

Guy: Grocery store


Review: "Old School market, Great selection of Italian meats, cheeses, olive oil ..."

There are no offers available.


Near Di Palo's Fine Foods:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

10. Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side

656 reviews
Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side
Location
4.8
Prices
4.8
Product Quality
4.4
Establishment
4.5
Customer service
4.9

Address: 1313 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10021, United States

Schedule: Opens at 8:00

Telephone: +1 212-874-0383

Guy: Gourmet grocery store


Review: "Best pastas, olive oils and vinegars."

There are no offers available.


Near Citarella Gourmet Market - Upper East Side:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

11. Kalustyan's


1118 reviews
Kalustyan's
Location
4.3
Prices
4.4
Product Quality
5
Establishment
4.9
Customer service
4.1

Address: 123 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States

Schedule: Opens at 10:00

Telephone: +1 212-685-3451

Guy: Indian grocery store


There are no offers available.


Near Kalustyan's:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

12. Eataly NYC Flatiron

7870 reviews
Eataly NYC Flatiron
Location
4.2
Prices
4.9
Product Quality
5
Establishment
4.2
Customer service
4.6

Address: 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, United States

Schedule: Closing soon: 22:00

Telephone: +1 212-229-2560

Guy: Grocery store


There are no offers available.


Near Eataly NYC Flatiron:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

13. Buon'Italia


86 reviews
Buon'Italia
Location
4.6
Prices
4.8
Product Quality
4.4
Establishment
4
Customer service
4.2

Address: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States

Schedule: Opens at 8:00

Telephone: +1 212-633-9090

Guy: Italian grocery store


There are no offers available.


Near Buon'Italia:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

14. Olive Grove Market

1 reviews
Olive Grove Market
Location
5
Prices
5
Product Quality
5
Establishment
5
Customer service
5

Address: 349 5th Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States

Telephone: +1 929-390-2450

Guy: Store


There are no offers available.


Near Olive Grove Market:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

15. Caputo's Fine Foods


72 reviews
Caputo's Fine Foods
Location
5
Prices
4.8
Product Quality
4.5
Establishment
4.4
Customer service
4.8

Address: 460 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, United States

Schedule: Opens at 9:00

Telephone: +1 718-855-8852

Guy: Gourmet grocery store


Review: "Fresh mozzarella, great selection of olives, coffee and pasta."

There are no offers available.


Near Caputo's Fine Foods:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

16. Frank and Sal Italian Market

157 reviews
Frank and Sal Italian Market
Location
4.6
Prices
4
Product Quality
4
Establishment
4.4
Customer service
4.9

Address: 4060 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10308, United States

Schedule: Opens at 8:00

Telephone: +1 718-966-7400

Guy: Italian grocery store


Review: "Great choice of various olives. Bought some sweets but haven't tried ..."

There are no offers available.


Near Frank and Sal Italian Market:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

17. Alleva Dairy


207 reviews
Alleva Dairy
Location
4
Prices
4.6
Product Quality
4.2
Establishment
5
Customer service
4.9

Address: 188 Grand St, New York, NY 10013, United States

Schedule: Opens at 10:00

Telephone: +1 212-226-7990

Guy: Cheese shop


There are no offers available.


Near Alleva Dairy:

Are you the owner of the business? PROMOTE IT!

  • Be the 1st in the ranking
  • exclusive page

Every week our algorithms find new sites and we only recommend the top 20 . next update in 144 minutes.


⭐️ If you promote or add your business, your listing will be permanent on this list.

We help you choose olive oil shops in New York

Looking for olive oil shops in New York? Then you've come to the right place, because we're all experts in it and all things New York!
We've got our finger on the pulse of the city, and we'll keep you up to date on the best places to eat, sleep and have a great time New York. Don't hesitate any longer, join us and use us in the palm of your hand to make sure you don't miss a single corner of one of the world's top cities - you're looking for olive oil shops in New York and here we are!
Don't just stop at the Empire State Building, MoMA or Central Park. Here you have everything and more available and updated for you to make the most of this city. Plans, hidden corners, and the most curious facts that can help you whether it's a trip for a couple of days or setting up a move New York.
Use us in your own way and find hundreds of useful posts about New York!